The Buyer’s Brief · Jewelry

Before You Buy Fine Jewelry

Natural or lab-grown and what the law requires, how to read a diamond report, what gold and platinum marks mean, Florida tax, auction fees and insurance. Sources are listed at the end.

Explore South Florida Jewelry →

Illustrative photo

By Everything Luxury · Sources checked November 15, 2026

SHARE
$1,500roughly the standard homeowners policy limit for jewelry theft (Insurance Information Institute)
7 per 1,000how far most gold jewelry, tested with its solder, may fall below its karat mark under federal law (15 U.S.C. 295)
13% to 14%year-over-year drops in lab-grown diamond wholesale prices in Q1 and Q2 2026 (Edahn Golan, via JCK)

01

Natural or Lab-Grown: What the Law Requires

Under the Federal Trade Commission’s Jewelry Guides, a laboratory-made stone must be described with a clear qualifier such as “laboratory-grown,” placed immediately before the stone name and just as prominent; “faux” is not enough. Sellers may not call a man-made stone “real,” “genuine” or “natural.” In 2018 the FTC removed the word “natural” from its definition of a diamond; a lab-grown stone still has to carry that clear qualifier. Ask for the disclosure in writing on the invoice.

02

Reading a Diamond Report

GIA grades natural diamonds on the 4Cs: color from D to Z, clarity in 11 grades from Flawless to I3, cut (for round brilliants) from Excellent to Poor, and carat weight (one carat is 200 milligrams). Before you buy, enter the report number in GIA Report Check: GIA says that if a report can be found there, it is authentic. GIA reports for lab-grown diamonds note that the girdle is inscribed “Laboratory-Grown,” and since the end of 2025 GIA describes lab-grown stones as “premium” or “standard” rather than grading them on the 4Cs.

03

What Gold and Platinum Marks Mean

Mark or termWhat it means
14K, 18KKarat gold; under federal law most jewelry may test no more than 7 parts per 1,000 below the mark when tested with its solder (3 parts per 1,000 without solder), and a maker’s trademark must accompany a quality mark
Gold filledA layer of at least 10K gold that is at least 1/20 of the item’s total metal weight
Gold plate (electroplate)At least 0.175 microns of 10K or better gold
VermeilSterling silver coated with at least 2.5 microns of 10K or better gold
950 Plat, 900 Plat, 850 PlatParts per 1,000 of platinum; below 500 it may not be called platinum, and between 500 and 850 the other metals must be disclosed

A rhodium surface layer must also be disclosed (FTC Jewelry Guides).

04

What Florida Taxes

Florida charges 6% sales tax on jewelry delivered in Florida. The county surtax applies only to the first $5,000 of each item: 1% in Miami-Dade and Broward and 0.5% in Palm Beach County in 2026. Jewelry bought outside Florida and brought in without Florida tax owes use tax, with credit for a similar tax paid to another state. Ask a Florida tax adviser about your own purchase.

05

Buying at Auction

Auction houses add a buyer’s premium in bands. In New York, Phillips charges 29% up to $2 million, 22% to $8 million and 15% above (from April 12, 2026), and Sotheby’s charges 28%, 22% and 15% on the same bands. Christie’s is reported at 27% up to $1.5 million, 22% to $8 million and 15% above (The Art Newspaper). Read each sale’s conditions for the exact bands and fees.

06

Insurance and Appraisal

A standard homeowners policy generally limits jewelry theft to about $1,500 (Insurance Information Institute). To cover more, schedule the piece on a floater or endorsement, which usually needs a professional appraisal first. No federal or state law licenses jewelry appraisers, so Jewelers of America suggests looking for gemological training such as GIA’s Graduate Gemologist; the American Society of Appraisers offers its own credentials. Florida’s Department of Financial Services suggests updating your home inventory every year.

Five Checks Before You Pay

  1. Natural or lab-grown, in writing on the invoice.
  2. The grading report number, checked on GIA Report Check.
  3. The metal mark and the maker’s trademark.
  4. The return, warranty and buyback terms, in writing.
  5. An appraisal for insurance, then call your insurance agent before you wear it out.

07

The Market Right Now

Gold was quoted at about $3,883 an ounce and platinum at about $1,487 on November 14, 2026 (Kitco). Natural diamond prices for one-carat stones fell 0.9% in October 2026 (Rapaport). Lab-grown diamond wholesale prices were down 14% year over year in the first quarter and 13% in the second quarter of 2026 (Edahn Golan, via JCK).

08

Where the Major Jewelry Houses Are

HouseSouth Florida boutiques
CartierRoyal Poinciana Plaza, Palm Beach · Town Center at Boca Raton · Aventura Mall · Design District: 147 NE 39th St
Tiffany & Co.259 Worth Ave · Bal Harbour Shops · Town Center at Boca Raton · Aventura Mall · The Gardens Mall · Design District: 160 NE 40th St
Van Cleef & Arpels202 Worth Ave · Bal Harbour Shops · Design District: 140 NE 39th St
BvlgariBal Harbour Shops · Design District: 140 NE 39th St
Harry WinstonBal Harbour Shops
GraffBal Harbour Shops (listed by the center as relocating soon)
Shopping in South Florida? See the major houses on South Florida Luxury Jewelry and South Florida Luxury Shopping.

Keep a Link to This Brief

We’ll email you a link back to this brief on Everything Luxury. You’ll also receive the Everything Luxury Insider every Thursday. We never sell or share your details, and you can unsubscribe anytime.

Looking for a specific piece? Talk to us, in confidence →

Sources (34) · checked November 15, 2026
  • FTC, Guides for the Jewelry, Precious Metals, and Pewter Industries (16 CFR Part 23): source
  • GIA, The 4Cs of diamond quality: source
  • FTC, Revisions to the Jewelry Guides (2018): source
  • GIA, Laboratory-grown diamond reports: source
  • GIA, Report Check: source
  • GIA, Is my report authentic? (FAQ): source
  • GIA, Diamond clarity: source
  • GIA, Diamond cut: source
  • GIA, Diamond carat weight: source
  • GIA announcement on lab-grown grading (June 2025, via Media OutReach): source
  • National Gold and Silver Marking Act, 15 U.S.C. 295: source
  • 15 U.S.C. 297 (trademark with quality mark): source
  • Florida Statutes s. 212.054 (surtax, $5,000 cap): source
  • Florida Statutes s. 212.06 (use tax, credit for other states): source
  • Florida DOR, Discretionary sales surtax rates 2026: source
  • Phillips, Buyer’s premium schedule: source
  • Sotheby’s, What is a buyer’s premium: source
  • The Art Newspaper, auction buyer’s premiums (Feb 17, 2026): source
  • Insurance Information Institute, Special coverage for jewelry and other valuables: source
  • Jewelers of America, Jewelry appraisals: source
  • American Society of Appraisers, Gems and jewelry: source
  • Florida DFS, Homeowners insurance toolkit: source
  • Kitco, gold price chart: source
  • Kitco, platinum price chart: source
  • Rapaport, diamond prices (Nov 3, 2026): source
  • JCK, lab-grown diamond prices (Edahn Golan): source
  • JCK, lab-grown demand and value: source
  • Cartier store locator: source
  • Tiffany & Co., Worth Avenue: source
  • Tiffany & Co., Miami Design District: source
  • Cartier, Palm Beach: source
  • Van Cleef & Arpels boutiques: source
  • Bal Harbour Shops directory: source
  • Miami Design District directory: source

Everything Luxury is an independent guide and does not sell, grade or appraise jewelry. Not legal, tax, insurance or financial advice; check coverage with a licensed insurance agent and tax questions with a tax adviser. Full disclaimer